While there’s no arguing that horror movies are the best genre to bring added chills to your autumn evenings, in our opinion, horror collectibles bring the chills for the best holiday gift ideas. If you still have some loved ones to shop for, the good news is that we’ve selected some popular items to make gift-giving easy. Naturally, no ho-ho-horror season would be complete with some spine-chilling holiday gift ideas to get you excited to get your shopping done. 

Toony Terrors Action Figures

As a chance to gift an experience along with a physical item, our Toony Terror Action Figures allow recipients to relive time spent watching Saturday morning cartoons. As one of our hand-picked selections for some scary-good holiday gift ideas, choose from these genre favorites: The Grady Twins from The Shining, Bloody Ash from The Evil Dead, and Jaws & Quint from Jaws. Standing 6” tall with no assembly required, anyone would be lucky to receive one (or more) of these figurines in their stocking.

Vacuum Form Masks

Many shoppers aren’t aware of just how vast our collection of Vacuum Form Masks is! Often overlooked by the more popular Jason Hockey Masks, these face coverings are unique and detailed. Made from PET plastic, using 3D-printer molds the faces of your favorite genre characters come straight to life. That said, since they are made of cheaper plastic, they are priced affordably, making them great holiday gift ideas for horror lovers on your shopping list. 


We’re not sure what your holiday traditions are, but for many, it includes an ornament for the tree. While horrornaments are in short supply this year, there are still many eerie-sistable ones to choose from including this doll head horrornament, this bat house horrornament, and this clown head horrornament. Order yours today and wrap up something haunting to place into your loved ones stocking.


Since the time-honored saying goes, “eat, DRINK, and be merry”, why not wrap up some horror drinkware as a practical holiday gift idea? We’ve got simple cups and coffee mugs for everyday use and fancy goblets for those witchier days. Plus, novelty items like shot glasses and bottle openers for your loved ones who’re 21+! 

You will slay the season with any of the above holiday gift ideas from Nightmare Toys!

Click here to shop horror stockings

What other horror items do you think would make great holiday gift ideas? Drop the category name in the comments section below to share. 

November 25, 2022 — Jeff Lew